Homeowners Are Slashing Prices In This Popular Region—Is There a Golden Opportunity For Investors?

Homeowners Are Slashing Prices In This Popular Region—Is There a Golden Opportunity For Investors?

For years, the U.S. housing market has been constrained by a lack of inventory, driving prices up despite rising interest rates. However, a recent Redfin report has revealed an unexpected increase in housing inventory along Florida’s Gulf Coast, catching many by surprise.

Significant Inventory Increases in Florida

According to Redfin, Western Florida’s Gulf Coast, including areas like Cape Coral and North Port, has seen a dramatic 50% rise in inventory compared to last year. This surge is the highest in the United States, providing a welcome respite for buyers and investors.

Other parts of Florida are also experiencing inventory growth. North Port-Sarasota saw a 48% increase, while West Palm Beach, known for attracting New York’s Tri-State area residents, reported a 20% rise in available homes.

Despite this increase in listings, sales have not followed suit. In fact, sales have decreased in several areas. Jacksonville, for instance, experienced a 27% drop in sales, and even Miami saw an almost 9% decline.

Recent data from March further supports these trends:

  • Home sales in Florida dropped 11.3% year over year.
  • The average days on market increased by 8 days.
  • Inventory rose by 28%.
  • The housing supply doubled from two to four months.

Why Are Prices Dropping?

The decline in prices can be attributed to several factors:

Overpricing: Eric Auciello, a local Redfin sales manager, noted that two years ago, North Port was one of the most competitive markets due to its affordability and limited housing supply. However, these factors are no longer present, and areas like Sarasota have been overvalued for years.

Decline in Remote Workers: As the pandemic recedes, many employers are requiring employees to return to the office, either full-time or on a hybrid basis. CNBC reported that 80% of companies will track office attendance in 2024, and non-compliant employees may face consequences such as job loss or reduced bonuses. During the pandemic, Florida's warm climate and lack of state income tax attracted many remote workers, but the recall to offices has likely reduced this influx.

High Insurance Costs: Florida has been hit hard by recent hurricanes, leading to increased insurance costs, higher property taxes, and a rising overall cost of living. Erin Sykes, chief economist at Nest Seekers International, pointed out that while the absence of state income tax benefits high earners, other living costs remain prohibitive. Consequently, Florida’s appeal is now more about political and business-friendly environments than affordability.

Soaring HOA Fees: The Florida real estate market, particularly condo sales, has been affected by rising HOA fees due to inflation. For instance, residents in Altamonte Springs have seen their fees nearly double, and new legislation following the Surfside condo collapse has increased costs for high-rise buildings.

A report by Insurify projects a 7% increase in insurance premiums for 2024, bringing the average annual cost for Florida residents to around $11,759.

Competition from Other Regions: Historically, New Yorkers have moved to Florida to escape the cold. The U.S. Census Bureau named Florida the fastest-growing state in 2022. However, other Southern states are now attracting new residents due to better job opportunities and lower living costs.


While Florida’s increase in housing inventory offers potential opportunities for buyers and investors, several factors are influencing the market dynamics, from decreased demand due to the return to office work, to high insurance and living costs. Understanding these elements is crucial for anyone looking to navigate the current real estate landscape in the Sunshine State.

You Might Also Like

  • Housing Prices: Only One Major Market is Seeing Housing Prices Decline Right Now
  • Home Prices Stagnate in The South and America’s New #1 Housing Market
  • Home Prices in Pittsburgh Are Up 22%, Making It The Fastest Gainer in the U.S.—Here’s Why Prices There are Exploding
  • Where Home Prices Grew the Most (and the Least) in 2023

Let's Talk

You’ve got questions and we can’t wait to answer them.